We will no doubt face this same revolutionary question again, I’m not so sure it was handled correctly. Any analysis from better read comrades?

  • ComradeRat [he/him, they/them]@hexbear.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    31
    ·
    5 days ago

    I follow Fidel’s line on the issue. He discusses it in his autobiography, p. 271-291.

    On 26 October 1962 Fidel wrote to Khrushchev:

    Dear Companero Khrushchev,

    After analysis of the situation and the reports in our possession, I consider aggression to be almost imminent — within the next twenty-four to seventy-two hours.

    There are two possible variants: the first and most probable is an air attack against certain objectives with the limited aim of destroying them; the second, which is less pribably though entirely possible, is invasion. In my view, this variant would demand a large force and is also the most repugnant form of aggression, which may deter them.

    You may be sure that we will offer firm and determined resistance to an attack, whichever the case. The morale of the Cuban people is extremely high, and we will face the aggressor heroically.

    I wish in these moments to give you, very briefly, a personal opinion.

    Should the second variant take place and the imperialists invade Cuba with the intention of occupying [the country], the dangers of this aggressive policy for humanity are so great that after such an event theSoviet Union must never allow circumstances in which the imperialists might carry out a nuclear first strike against it.

    I say this because I believe that the imperialists’ aggressiveness has become extremely dangerous, and if they do indeed perform an act so brutal and in such brazen violation of universal law and morality as invading Cuba, that would be the moment to eliminate that danger for ever, in an act of the most legitimate self-defence. However hard and terrible the solution might be, there is no other.

    This opinion is influenced by my having observed the evolution of this aggressive policy, the way the imperialists, in defiance of world opinion and [considering themselves] above principle and law, have blockaded the seas, violated our airspace, and are now preparing for invasion, while they thwart every possibility of negotiation, despite knowing the gravity of the situation.

    You have been and are a tireless defender of peace; I understand how bitter these hours must be for you, when the results of your superhuman efforts are so seriously threatened. Until the last moment, however, we shall maintain our hope that peace may be salvaged, and we are willing to contribute whatever may be within our reach [to achieve that goal]. But at the same time, we are ready to face with serenity a situation which we see as very real and very imminent.

    I convey to you once again the infinite gratitude of the Cuban people to the Soviet people, who have been so generous and fraternal with us, and our profound gratitude and admiration to you [personally], as well as our desires for success in the enormous task and grave responsibilities that you have in your hands.

    Fraternally, Fidel Castro

    Khrushchev sent a reply on 28 October saying the U.S. will make peace any day, so stop shooting down their spy planes and provoking them because that “will be used by aggressors to their advantage.”

    Fidel replied the same day saying basically that Cuba would hold their fire while the negotiations were ongoing unless they see a bomber, and telling Khrushchev Cuba opposes inspections of Cuban territory on principle.

    Khrushchev replied on the 30th after the crisis was “resolved”, taking issue with Fidel’s advocacy on the 26th for a first strike if Cuba were invaded, because while it would harm the imperialists, “the entire Socialist camp would also have suffered terribly. With respect to Cuba, the Cuban people, it is hard to say how it would have turned out. In the first place, the fires of war would have burned Cuba. There is no doubt that the Cuban people would have fought valiantly, but that it would also have perished heroically cannot be doubted.” He claims that “as a result of the measures we have taken, we have achieved the objecitve we set ourselves when we entered our agreement with you to send the missiles to Cuba. We have extracted from the United States the commitement that they themselves will not attack Cuba”, which is “lol, lmao, lmfao” especially looking back from 2026.

    Fidel was pretty pissed (especially since Khrushchev’s letter was pretty condescending, acting like Cuban’s didn’t know what massive destruction nuclear war would mean) and wrote a reply on October 31:

    The eyes of many men, Soviet and Cuban, who were willing to die with supreme dignity, wept when they learned of the surprising, unexpected, and practically unconditional decision to withdraw the weapons.

    You may not know to what degree the Cuban people were prepared to fulfil their duty to the patria and to humanity.

    I was not unaware when I wrote them that the words of my letter by be misinterpreted by you, and so they have been, perhaps because you did not read them slowly and carefully, perhaps because of the translation, perhaps because I tried to say too much in too few lines. However I did not hesitate to write. Do you think, Comrade Khrushchev, that we were thinking selfishly of ourselves, of our generous people ready to immolate themselves, and not, of course, unconsciously, but fully assured of the risk we ran?

    We knew — do not assume that we didn’t — that we might be exterminated, as you insinuate in your letter, should a thermonuclear war break out. Still that did not persuade us to ask you to withdraw the missiles, or ask you to give in. Do you think we wanted that war? But how were we to avoid it if the invasion had occurred? It was precisely because such an invasion was possible, that imperialism might thwart every solution — and from our point of view, their demands were impossible to accept, by either the USSR or Cuba.

    And if such an event had occurred, what was one to do with the madmen who unleashed the war? You yourself have said that in the current conditions, war will inevitably become thermonuclear war, and quickly so.

    It is my position that once the aggression has occurred, the aggressors must not be given the privilege to decide when nuclear arms will be used. The destructive power of these weapons is so great, and the means of transporting them so swift, that the aggressor can count on a considerable initial advantage in his favour.

    I.e., as I understand it: the USSR was wrong to withdraw the missiles (particularly doing so unilaterally, against Cubans’ will) and should never have backed down against the U.S. If we fear nuclear blackmail, we’ll never defeat imperialism. Or as Molotov put it in his memoirs:

    In dealing with imperialism is it possible to say, live and let live? If so, permit me to ask: what are we living for? If it is for the overthrow of imperialism, can we possibly coexist peacefully without overthrowing imperialism? Are we renouncing the overthrow of imperialism? No, we are not. How then is it possible to combine peaceful coexistence with the overthrow of imperialism? According to the Communist Manifesto, “The communists do not conceal their views. They stand for the violent overthrow of the entire existing social order.” This is basic to Marx and to Lenin. Everything is reasoned out so as not to contradict this teaching, but now we preach peaceful coexistence. How does one fit in with the other? If they do jibe, then explain how. The real purpose of this expression is to set people’s minds at ease.

    More than a hundred years ago we were not afraid to speak out openly, and we rallied people into insurrection. But today we who have grown strong talk about peaceful coexistence. There can be only one long-range goal if we are to move forward: only international revolution. There is nothing, no alternative, more reliable than this. It is our duty to preserve peace. But if we believe that without international revolution we can fight for peace and delay war, if we still believe that it’s possible to arrive at communism in this way, that is deception from a Marxist viewpoint, both self-deception and deception of the people.

    Revolution is on the march, it is growing stronger, everything is moving forward, but not without sacrifices. He who thinks it is possible to advance to communism without sacrifices and without mistakes is naive. The fewer the mistakes the better, but there are bound to be some. Big mistakes that create illusions and spread complacency do not prepare us for decisive battles which are absolutely unavoidable. Thus nothing will be gained, and we shan’t move forward. This means that very big battles lie ahead. We are not preparing for them. This is the main danger as I see it…

    In fact, when Khrushchev launched “peaceful coexistence,” he did so for the most self-serving of reasons. After all, by playing up fear of atomic war, we help bring it on. Much lies ahead to be done. We proceed from the premise that our positions must be strengthened.

  • TabularTuxedo@lemmygrad.ml
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    25
    ·
    5 days ago

    Handled the Americans or by the Soviets?

    If it’s the Americans, they could have avoided the Cuban Missile Crisis by not placing nukes next to the USSR. Since they repeated the exact same thing with Ukraine (by inviting them to NATO), I don’t think trusting the West to not push boundaries is wise.

    The thing is that our world is not the same as it was in the Crisis. Like, it was feasible for the US to want to nuke the Soviet Union, but not so much nuke China because all their stuff is made there.

    China’s strategy is basically make it impossible for the US to ever decouple from China’s industry. Whether that will avoid WWIII remains to be seen.

      • TabularTuxedo@lemmygrad.ml
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        16
        ·
        5 days ago

        Then I don’t know what they could’ve done.

        Maybe they should’ve established the Moscow-Washington hotline earlier to avoid communication issues. Like, I can imagine a scenario where the US places nukes in Turkiye, then the Kremlin puts nukes in Moscow and calls Washington like “Look, we have placed nukes in Cuba in retaliation for you placing nukes in Turkiye, let’s negociate.”

        I’m sure it would’ve caused a crisis, but at least both sides wouldn’t be in the dark.

        • davel@lemmygrad.ml
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          12
          ·
          5 days ago

          STRANGELOVE Of course, the whole point of a Doomsday Machine is lost if you keep it a secret! Why didn’t you tell the world, eh?

          AMBASSADOR It was to be announced at the Party Congress on Monday. As you know, the Premier loves surprises.

      • demeritum@lemmygrad.ml
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        14
        arrow-down
        1
        ·
        5 days ago

        It was just empty posturing by the US, they had already planned to move the nukes out of Turkey. Khrushchev, in the end, only abandoned Cuba and directly caused the decades of economic hardship and isolation faced by Cuba.

        • Red_Scare [he/him]@lemmygrad.ml
          link
          fedilink
          arrow-up
          4
          ·
          edit-2
          5 days ago

          Khrushchev, and USSR at large, did not abandon Cuba until it collapsed under Gorbachev decades later. The special period was caused by that collapse, not by any abandonement by the USSR. Under Brezhnev, Cuba and USSR agreed to exchange goods based on labour content rather than international market price, which was extremely beneficial to Cuba. You have no idea what you’re talking about and it’s not the first time either.

  • pcalau12i@lemmygrad.ml
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    19
    arrow-down
    1
    ·
    5 days ago

    Hindsight is 20/20. From the USSR’s perspective, they did not anticipate that they would cease to exist, so they saw negotiating for nuclear dismemberment as an indefinite long-lasting policy, because they would always be there to make sure the US abides by it. They got everything they wanted. By placing nukes in Cuba, they got the US to both promise never to invade Cuba again, as well as to remove nukes from Turkey, in exchange for the USSR pulling their nukes from Cuba.

    The issue is, of course, the USSR no longer exists, and so those promises the US made are no longer seen as binding, and so both of those gains have been lost. This means it probably would have ultimately been better to just let Cuba keep the nukes. If the USSR let Cuba keep the nukes, at least the deterrence from a US invasion would remain post-USSR dissolution. But that kind of calculation really only makes sense in hindsight knowing that the USSR later dissolved.

    At the time it is understandable why the Soviets did not make that calculation, even though it was ultimately the wrong decision. I think in general the Soviets had a problem of creating dependence of other socialist countries on themselves, because then it made the socialist movement centered around them, which is why when they collapsed, so many other socialist countries immediately disappeared with it. I think it is a good lesson to try and focus on promoting another socialist country’s independence as much possible; letting Cuba keep the nukes lets it defend itself without depending on the USSR’s eternal existence to protect it.

    • Red_Scare [he/him]@lemmygrad.ml
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      3
      arrow-down
      1
      ·
      edit-2
      5 days ago

      Soviets had a problem of creating dependence of other socialist countries on themselves, because then it made the socialist movement centered around them, which is why when they collapsed, so many other socialist countries immediately disappeared with it.

      But there were more non-aligned socialist states in the 20th century than Soviet bloc states, and what did this achieve? Almost all of them collapsed around 1985 - 1992 (a few others didn’t even survive that long). It’s not a coincidence Gorbachev took power in 1985 and ended the USSR policy of support for revolutionary movements abroad, focusing instead on detente and rapprochement with the USA.

      Some USSR-aligned states did survive the collapse of the USSR like DPRK, Laos, Vietnam, and Cuba, despite experiencing extreme economic hardship in the 90s and coming close to collapse.

      The only non-aligned socialist state to survive the 90s was China, only by totally subjugating their workers to the West, they had suicide nets just 15 years ago and they still didn’t restore the iron rice bowl.

      Had there been a more aligned and integrated communist bloc, economically, militarily, and in terms of foreign policy, USSR might’ve survived, along with all those other states, and the peoples of China, Cuba etc could be spared immense suffering.

      [Edit]

      If the USSR let Cuba keep the nukes, at least the deterrence from a US invasion would remain post-USSR dissolution.

      Those were Soviet, not Cuban nukes just the same as nukes in Turkey were US nukes, not Turkish nukes. Post-USSR dissolution they would become Russian nukes, and Yeltsin’s comprador Russia would give them up in a heartbeat - and to be honest a hypothetical Zyuganov’s Russia would too cause it had absolutely no power to project. Cuba would not magically gain real material ability to launch them and if Cuba tried to take over the nukes illegally, against all the international treaties, they would become a rogue state and US absolutely would invade, immediately, before the Cubans gained real material ability to launch them. This is exactly the same as “Ukrainian” nukes, simply no such thing.

      • pcalau12i@lemmygrad.ml
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        4
        arrow-down
        1
        ·
        4 days ago

        I was talking about dependence not alignment. And obviously me saying letting Cuba keep the nukes would mean they would become Cuban nukes. So neither of your main points really seems relevant to what I was talking about in my comment. I’m not sure why you think nukes are magic, the USSR could have given the ability to launch them over to the Cuban military. Your claim that the US would invade a nuclear armed power because they are a “rogue state” seems rather questionable given that the US has never invaded the DPRK and it is considered a rogue state, and Cuba is treated as a rogue state anyways and given the same DPRK treatment without having nukes.

        • Red_Scare [he/him]@lemmygrad.ml
          link
          fedilink
          arrow-up
          2
          ·
          edit-2
          4 days ago

          I think my reply was relevant to your comment but I’m happy to expand.

          Soviets had a problem of creating dependence of other socialist countries on themselves, because then it made the socialist movement centered around them, which is why when they collapsed, so many other socialist countries immediately disappeared with it.

          creating dependence -> if you meant something like Cuba, where USSR was a major purchaser of sugar, so when USSR collapsed, their economy, boycotted by the rest of the world, collapsed too, then my answer was: I think more economic integration was needed, not less. That does mean some countries having less diversified economies, not every place is equally good for growing sugarcane for instance. If you meant something different, please explain because I have no idea what other dependence USSR cultivated in their allies.

          socialist movement centered around them -> my answer was that foreign policy, military doctrine etc needed to be even more integrated and that does mean someone taking the central role. I think USSR was best positioned to take the lead. To show USSR lead was bad you’d have to point at what they’ve done wrong. Stopped the fascist uprising in Hungary? Prevented liberal reform in Czechoslovakia? If anything, they intervened too little, like they should’ve intervened in Afghanistan at the first request for military aid and not let Amin take power. Romania was a Warsaw Pact member but it pursued “it’s own path” against Moscow guidance without much consequence, from supporting Israel to taking out IMF loans which destroyed Romania. I don’t want to sound authoritarian but maybe a little bit of falling in line would’ve done good to everyone. Again if I misunderstood what you meant by USSR trying to centre socialist movement around them, please explain.

          And since we’re at it, USSR materially helped anti-colonial and revolutionary movements that proceeded to pursue non-aligned policy. That didn’t cause USSR to make their support conditional on entry to the Warsaw pact, in fact they supported the Non-Aligned Movement. So if you wanted USSR to afford other socialist and post-colonial states greater independence then rejoice! Because it did, and you have Khrushchev to thank for it. For Stalin, there was only the socialist camp lead by Moscow and the capitalist camp led by Washington, he totally denounced Tito for pursuing independence.

          socialist countries immediately disappeared with it -> my answer was that actually most socialist states followed your prescription yet they perished the same. When USSR dropped support for foreign revolutions and instead focused on the US, the West didn’t have to worry anymore about those states joining the Soviet bloc, so they could be much more aggressive with sanctions, espionage, sabotage and so on.

          In general I’m not quite sure what you mean by “I was talking about dependence not alignment.” What should USSR have done differently to not create dependence while maintaining alignment?

          To be frank, your comment reads like you’re suggesting USSR was practising imperialism (that’s what cultivating dependence in other countries is) just cause they lusted for power (that’s what “because then it made the socialist movement centered around them” means), and that’s an extremely liberal take.

          And obviously me saying letting Cuba keep the nukes would mean they would become Cuban nukes.

          So you think USSR should go around giving out nukes to other socialist states? I’m guessing they’d also need to transfer entire capacity to develop, build, maintain, and operate nuclear arsenal, as to not make other countries dependent, right? And then sit back and let them do whatever they want as to not take too central a role?

          USSR has always been a peaceful country, under Stalin USSR repeatedly advocated for complete nuclear disarmament and reduction of standing armies. USSR collapsing doesn’t make it a bad policy. It’s a good thing we’ve had so long since the last nukes fell.

          I’m not sure why you think nukes are magic

          I’m ignorant like that. We’re simple folk.

          Your claim that the US would invade a nuclear armed power because they are a “rogue state” seems rather questionable given that the US has never invaded the DPRK and it is considered a rogue state, and Cuba is treated as a rogue state anyways and given the same DPRK treatment without having nukes.

          That’s not what I said though, is it? I said if Cuba tried to illegally seize the nukes they don’t actually control, the US would invade before Cubans could figure out how to use them.

          • pcalau12i@lemmygrad.ml
            link
            fedilink
            English
            arrow-up
            3
            arrow-down
            1
            ·
            4 days ago

            My point is that your first argument only works if we assume the USSR does not collapse. How is more integration with a country that collapses a good thing? As I said in my original comment, such policy made sense at the time, and so this analysis only makes sense with hindsight. I’m sure if the Cubans knew the USSR was going to completely collapse they would have strived to speed up becoming economically independently.

            My point was not about intervention, that is again a separate topic. Intervening in a country doesn’t mean you make them dependent upon yourself. There’s also different kinds of dependence, such as ideological as well as economic. Cuba was not ideologically dependent upon the USSR because it had its own grassroots movement with legitimacy, so the USSR falling didn’t end the project because there was enough grassroots support to keep the project going.

            So many countries were taken out by the USSR’s fall not just because of economic dependence, which a lot of them were, but also because of ideological dependence. Jin Huiming discusses this in his “Marxism and Socialism with Chinese Characteristics,” that the Soviets outright rejected the idea of a country implementing socialism with their own characteristics, and believed every model needed to look the same: exactly like the USSR, and so they actually suppressed many grassroots socialist movements on this basis.

            This, in my view, then created an ideological dependence where the socialist leadership’s legitimacy rested specifically on Moscow and not a grassroots movement, which the USSR falling then made it fall easily.

            I’m also not sure where why you think I claimed that the Soviets should’ve dropped support for other socialist countries.

            • Self-reliance ≠ non-aligned
            • Self-reliance ≠ leave them out to dry and don’t support them
            • Self-reliance ≠ don’t intervene

            If anything, it means the opposite of all three: intervene and support heavily to rapidly build up the country’s ability to be militarily and economically self-reliant.

            So you think USSR should go around giving out nukes to other socialist states?

            USSR has always been a peaceful country, under Stalin USSR repeatedly advocated for complete nuclear disarmament and reduction of standing armies.

            nukes = peace

            Look what happened when Gaddafi gave up the nukes. He got invaded and now Libya is destroyed.

            USSR collapsing doesn’t make it a bad policy. It’s a good thing we’ve had so long since the last nukes fell.

            There is simply no historical precedent for the claim that socialist countries having nukes would lead to more nukes falling. All the examples we have from China to USSR to DPRK prove that the moment they acquire them there is peace.

            • Red_Scare [he/him]@lemmygrad.ml
              link
              fedilink
              arrow-up
              1
              ·
              edit-2
              3 days ago

              I’ll be blunt, I don’t know what you are talking about and neither do you. “Cuba was not ideologically dependent upon the USSR because it had its own grassroots movement with legitimacy” - OK so which USSR allies did not have their own legitimate grassroots movement, specifically?

              Throughout its entire history, despite constant shortages and often struggling economy, USSR consistently exported wealth and knowledge to its allies while competing with neocolonial Western powers which consistently pillaged the world of resources, labour, and talent. But not enough, the Soviet people should’ve experienced even more hardship in order to build up everyone else. USSR provided immense material support to revolutionary and anti-colonial movements abroad, you have no idea what kind of economic and military strain that is. But not enough, they should’ve stretched themselves even thinner, supporting all the movements that, according to Soviet revolutionary experience, did not stand a chance of survival. What are those “many grassroots socialist movements USSR suppressed”, specifically? Spanish anarchists? And what are those many successful revolutions China materially supported?

              What ideological dependence was there, specifically? I gave example of Romania, an “ideologically independent” Warsaw Pact country that supported Israel. Following Naksa USSR cut all ties with Israel and delivered arms, military transport and personnel, and financial assistance to Egypt and Syria which weren’t even Marxist-Leninist, does that sound like a country that doesn’t allow allies to pick their own path? Where was China then? Where is China now? Did they provide Assad’s Syria any assistance, or Iran, or Hezbollah? Or are they still among Israel’s top trading partners?

              Entire reason for Sino-Soviet split was that China considered Khrushchev’s reforms revisionist - but obviously those reforms weren’t nearly as revisionist as Deng’s reforms. You can’t simultaneously condemn Khrushchev as a revisionist while praising Deng for developing “own characteristics”! You can’t simultaneously condemn USSR for being too ideologically rigid while praising China for letting countries “implement their own characteristics” when it was China who started the biggest split in the socialist camp over reforms that were less revisionist than China’s own reforms a few decades later! All the while USSR materially supported very ideologically independent movements in Ghana, Congo, Libya, Mali, Mozambique, Angola, Namibia, South Africa, Guinea and Cape Verde… None of them were building a country “exactly like USSR”! And where’s China’s military support for Sahel states now? You can’t simultaneously condemn USSR for not doing enough while absolving China for doing nothing.

              The Sino-Soviet split led China to align itself with USA against the USSR. They supported jihadists in Afghanistan against the legitimate socialist government which directly leads to creation of Al-Queda and ISIS, this extremism China helped USA create will spill out into Chechnya in Russian Federation and into Xinjiang in China itself - none of that would happen if China stood with USSR and the legitimate Afghan government. By the way Afghan war was one of the main reasons for USSR collapse. The Sino-Soviet split would lead China to support Pol Pot (again together with USA) against USSR-aligned Vietnam. What other “ideologically independent socialist movements” did China materially support, specifically?

              I think this quote from the 1963 Khrushchev letter to Castro sums it up:

              You may have observed that certain people and groups, and even the leaders of certain socialist countries, who limited themselves to observing the crisis, started to get agitated and to pontificate on the ways in which one should have acted during the crisis, criticizing those who carried the burden of the struggle. They say that we should have proceeded in this or that way, taken such-and-such a step, although they themselves took no steps and held themselves at the sidelines of the real struggle. We may rightly ask these critics why they, at the height of the crisis, did not take any step — verbal or material — that would have demonstrated their willingness to aid Cuba, to march with you if war broke out.

              In those days, those critics gave no proof of any such willingness and limited themselves to insulting capitalism and imperialism. Were we to compete with them in this practice, we would win the contest easily: it is well known that the Russian language has an enormous number of insults.

              And now as your country is preparing to invade Cuba again while China kicks back and cracks open a cold one, it’s all USSR fault! They should’ve given Cuba nukes! Why not ask the current nuclear socialist power, China, to gift some nukes around? Why is this responsibility of the country that disappeared 35 years ago?

              OK let’s follow your thought through. Who else should USSR have given nukes? Why not Ghana under Kwame Nkrumah, a brilliant revolutionary leader who’s “Neocolonialism, the last stage of imperialism” is a seminal work on imperialism and any reading of Lenin’s “Imperialism, the highest stage of capitalism” is incomplete without it? Why not Burkina Faso under Sankara? Of course both governments collapsed due to internal coups so no nukes would’ve prevented that… And what would happen then?

              I’m so glad you understand nukes are not magic, cause that means you understand by “giving” other countries nukes USSR would be giving up its nuclear command setup, launch procedures, targeting systems, safety and maintenance protocols, communications, technical documentation, engineering knowledge, it’s entire nuclear doctrine. Do you know what would happen if NATO got their hands on it?

              In fact, something very similar did happen - USSR assisted China in developing their own nuclear programme, and then China turned its back on USSR and aligned itself with the literal United States of America instead. But of course USSR should’ve just kept going and create more nuclear powers and let them align with the mortal enemy of entire international working class.

              But why stop there, why not “give nukes” to Poland, Czechoslovakia, Romania, Bulgaria, Hungary, DDR? You do know all of those countries collaped in 1989, before the USSR collapse in 1991, not in the aftermath of USSR collapse, right? What would happen then, when USSR was surrounded by newly hostile capitalist states?

              But hey, why stop even there! When USSR dissolved in 1991, a lot of republics were still socialist: Georgia would stay socialist until 1995, Moldova until 1994, Ukraine until 1996, Tajikistan 1994, Uzbekistan 1992, Kyrgyzstan 1993 (the last 3 are now breeding ground for Islamic extremism that is responsible for terrorist attacks in Russian Federation and elsewhere). Should Russia have given away some nukes and all the relevant doctrine as a goodbye gift so those newly independent socialist states can fend off capitalist aggression?


              I’ve been engaging with you in good faith but all you contributed were snide remarks, smug memes, and a title of this one book you read. Not a single specific example. So I won’t be engaging with you further.

  • Jeanne-Paul Marat@lemmygrad.ml
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    edit-2
    4 days ago

    I’ll admit this isnt my area of expertise. But I’ll give it a go

    I definitely think there should’ve been a more official agreement reached by the end of the crisis. The US was already planning on moving nukes out of turkey, so certain guarantees like removing the embargo [partially at least] or a proper treaty like emerged later with the weapon limitation agreements. Of course, whether this could have happened or not is a tough question, considering any capitulation to the soviets by Kennedy might have come of as being “soft on communism.”

    Edit: or conversely, the soviets should have demanded a formal treaty and acknowledgement of US withdrawal of missiles from turkey. The us probably wouldn’t have agreed to this, but it would have put Kennedy between a rock and a hard place. Although, of course, avoiding nuclear war was probably a better choice imo