A socialist economy stable in the fulfillment of their 5 year plans & fully established with state industries of an early commodity production type as of the first socialist camp but a step further. That step being when all the collective industries are finally converted to state, then the economy can take the great leap towards ending commodity production. That leap being a well planned transition to a labor voucher system which could resemble the following prescription for how to do so.
Carry over the purchasing power of the worker from the commodity system to the voucher system as a stand in for carrying over the value of wages:payments dispersed. Prices and payments will be exactly proportional in transit. 1 Soviet dollar = 1 digital labor dollar.
Then as automation advances relate the prices of common goods to the increasing productive capacity in order to reflect the measured decrease in value contained in the goods as determined by the unit change of (Socially Necessary Labor Time) SNLT to produce them.
By relation of productive capacity I mean in the conditions created by a common goods’ SNLT to produce being decreased which would bring an increase in the value of wages which carry either a deflationary nature on lowering prices or a shortening of the working day. If production can be doubled in the same time by next year but the price stays the same so the workers may take more time off in good proportion that is a gain still.
As automation increases prices converge towards zero and aid socialism in overcoming scarcity giving workers ample free time & a deflationary wage increase which generalizes the wealth traditionally only relegated to the petite bourgeoisie thus undermining the basis of social democracy. Production since on a planned basis would be sustainable. Some goods would not have a price for artificial demand constraint but would be allocated per person. This seems best facilitated by a labour voucher system.
In regard to international trade with other socialist states another Comecon should exist and utilize a non transferable currency to quantify the values traded on the ledger. This would be a solid step towards trading in use values until wage labor itself is safely made obsolete and the question of international trade fairness is made into a question of sustainable & moral production in relation to ecology which includes the people.
Although commodities no longer exist domestically or within the socialist camp, there is still a withering period in regard to international trade. Until capitalism is globally uprooted, socialist states may export commodities only for the securement of important inputs from capitalist nations. We secure steel to forge an economic spear. International trade between socialist states remains decommodified. In the end the state becomes a widow for her late class society based on surplus labor is dead. The bourgeoisie’s existence, the existence of commodity production is finally finally by the spinning wheel!
What ends commodity production is the socialization of production which occurs even under capitalist societies. Imagine an economy that is dominated by three enterprises, A, B, and C, which trade with each other. Then, let’s say enterprise A buys up B. Now A-B is a single enterprise, and so whatever commodities were traded between A and B have now left the realm of commodity circulation and are just directly planned internally inside of the combined A-B enterprise. Of course, commodity production has not as a whole disappeared, as commodities still flow between enterprises A-B and C, but its scope has diminished.
People tend to take Marx’s descriptions of development trend of socialist societies as prescriptions for policies to implement, as if his prediction that post-capitalist society would begin to move beyond commodity production as if it is a prescription to pass a law to make commodity production illegal and any community party that doesn’t pass such a law are “evil revisionists” who have “betrayed the revolution.” But, really, commodity production is something that withers away, like the state, through the socialization of production, which is an unconscious process that is carried out deterministically by the development of the forces of production.
Post-scarcity is not actually necessary to end commodity production. All that is necessary is that the production process becomes so complicated that it is not meaningfully possible for it to be carried out by small enterprise, and everything becomes centralized into the hands of a single firm. Workers at that firm may still be “paid,” but what they are paid in would necessarily have to be spent back at that same enterprise, and thus there would be no circulation between enterprises, which is how Marx defined a labor voucher.
We already saw this in embryo in the USSR, which nationalized most everything, and so its ruble, while not purely a labor voucher as it still circulated internationally and between the kolkhoz, played the role of a labor voucher more often than playing the role of money.
Soviet socialism, particularly following the introduction of the first five-year plan under Stalin in the late 1920s, introduced a new and non-capitalist mode of extraction of a surplus. This is somewhat obscured by the fact that workers were still paid ruble wages, and that money continued in use as a unit of account in the planned industries, but the social content of these ‘monetary forms’ changed drastically. Under Soviet planning, the division between the necessary and surplus portions of the social product was the result of political decisions. For the most part, goods and labour were physically allocated to enterprises by the planning authorities, who would always ensure that the enterprises had enough money to ‘pay for’ the real goods allocated to them.
If an enterprise made monetary ‘losses’, and therefore had to have its money balances topped up with ‘subsidies’, that was no matter. On the other hand, possession of money as such was no guarantee of being able to get hold of real goods. By the same token, the resources going into production of consumer goods were centrally allocated. Suppose the workers won higher ruble wages: by itself this would achieve nothing, since the flow of production of consumer goods was not responsive to the monetary amount of consumer spending. Higher wages would simply mean higher prices or shortages in the shops. The rate of production of a surplus was fixed when the planners allocated resources to investment in heavy industry and to the production of consumer goods respectively.
— “Toward a New Socialism”
The reality is that the communist party does not need to plan a “transition” to a “labor voucher system” as some sort of policy goal. It occurs, again, naturally as a result of the socialization of production, which the latter occurs autonomously as a result of the development of the forces of production. So the party’s goal should be to encourage the development of the forces of production, and to find minimally disruptive ways of expropriating enterprises that have arisen to a national scale, as this will be a long drawn out process.
As long as Marx’s theory is right, then that is sufficient to eventually, in the very long-term of things, bring an end to commodity production, which is not something that happens immediately but is something very gradual, with the scope of commodity circulation constantly diminishing.
I also do not think international trade between socialist states can be meaningfully decommodified unless they actually merge into the same state, like under the structure of a union. Commodification is a natural consequence of decentralization, i.e. of individual production. It is the same reason why decentralized communal societies cannot work in the modern era. If they are not operating under the same plan, then naturally they will have their own independent book-keeping, and they will expect compensation for what they produce, and will find themselves producing things specifically for that compensation.
Really, commodity production cannot meaningfully go away in its entirety unless the whole world was socialized under a single global plan. Even if the world is dominated by socialist states, there will end up being commodity production between them. Leftcoms, who promote Marx’s predictions about future society to prescriptions as to what policies to implement, then declare this as proof that actually existing socialist states have “betrayed the revolution.” But really it just is what it is.
I don’t find it particularly rational to treat the complete purification of the world from every last commodity as a sort of eternal principle to actually be very rational to begin with, and is kind of missing the forest for the trees, as if the decommodification aspect of socialist society is what socialism is about, when it’s not. There are people who stress out like if a single kid has a lemonade stand where he is selling lemonade in a whole world economy that is planned, then somehow that is the end of socialism. Getting caught up in puritanical debates like this kind of misses the big picture of things.


