something you cooked from the bottom of your heart, inspired by that person, improvising with seasonal ingredients, with a touch of crazy zestiness (lime, ginger, chili)? something that would taste delicious and show how inventive and thoughtful you are!

This is an extremely valid and important question, I am so glad you asked it. Upvoted. Twice.

Tomato soup is definitely the bad one. It sucks in general.

I would also avoid anything with ‘chowder’ in the name. Idk, just never sat right with me.

The broccoli cream soup @lesnout27@feddit.de mentioned is a definite winner. And any soup that incorporates coconut as a cream or flavour.

Generally I think you would aim for lighter soups, rather than heavy and hearty with tons of solid veges and meat. And it must be compatible with dipping garlic bread.

Gazpacho is chilled; if that isn’t cool enough I’ll eat my sombrero.

Gazpacho

Tom Kha Ghai

Any soup is cool enough to eat on a first date. If your date gives you crap about something as inconsequential as what kind of soup you’re eating, your date should be discarded at your earliest convenience, because they have shown themselves to be an opinionated twat that will bitch about things that don’t matter in the slightest.

Consomme for the first date.
Double Consomme if you really care about him.
Triple Consomme if he is taken by the King to another duchy, and you don’t expect to see him for a long time.

Just don’t eat soup on a first date. Soup is a 38th date food. Soup is what you get at a little truck stop after being stuck in a blizzard together for the last 12 hours in a car with no working heater, on your way back from Christmas. Then you get some soup and empty little bags of oyster crackers into it and you look at her and smile because you’re lucky to be with her. “Ohhh that’s so good” she says, huffing the air over the soup, and tugging off her mittens.

If you had to eat soup on a first date, Pho is the way to go.

broccoli creme soup with ajvar is rather fancy, Kohlrabi creme soup would fit also

Ask for scalding hot dishwater to show that you’re hardcore. A bowl of hot sauce is also acceptable. /s

Shared bowl of all you can eat soup from Italian garden. I am not clarifying.

Gazpacho

I have a simple soup rule: if they judge you poorly for you or soup, judge them poorly as a person.

The answer to both questions is “ball soup”, but the pleasure varies between who’s giving and who’s receiving.

Childish jokes aside; pea and ham is a good soup for any occasion.

If you are worried about ordering the “wrong” soup, you aren’t mature enough to be dating yet. Discover yourself, then you can show show yourself to another person. Otherwise you are just wearing a mask.